Skip to main content

Criteria for Study Inclusion

The scope and nature of independent or gig work in the United States has attracted considerable attention from researchers in government, academia, the social sector, and the private sector. No single dataset, though, provides a comprehensive picture of the contemporary workforce. The largest and most reliable studies often cover only a limited set of questions; the language and definitions used across studies varies greatly, yielding widely different results; and the unique interests of some surveyors don’t lead to the most universally useful data.

On this site, we attempt to reconcile many studiessome of which appear contradictoryin order to generate insights about independent work. We rely most heavily on data that meet certain standards, outlined below. We also believe, though, that we can learn from exploratory and non-representative research that explores critical questions and areas that have not been covered by other sources, and draw from this research when we lack more rigorous data.

In applying these criteria, we do not use a singular definition of “independent work.” Instead, we use it as a general term and then look deeply at how others describe and define it (often using terms such as gig work, alternative work arrangements, independent contracting, or 1099 work).

Criteria for Study Inclusion
Content

We are interested in research that directly addresses independent workers. This includes attempts to measure the size and composition of the independent workforce and/or to describe the experiences of independent workers.

Research must present original data (survey, interviews, employment records, etc.) or contain original analysis of public datasets (CPS, GSS, tax data, etc.).

Definition Research must include a clear, internally consistent definition of independent work.
Measures All measures must be clearly identified and correspond to the definition used. Where applicable, Data Hub authors must have access to survey instrument or interview schedule language, either through public availability or by request.
Methods

Research must state sampling and recruitment methods, and present number of responses and response rate, where applicable. In synthesizing estimates of the independent workforce, we prioritize data that relies on a probability sample and documents attempts to increase representativeness.

Methods of analysis must be clear and replicable.

Sponsorship Funding source(s) of study must be identified.